Carbon Offsets: A Breakdown of Their Function and Mechanisms

Carbon offsets: The red-hot climate solution – but do they genuinely help? What's the deal with carbon offsetting?

Whew, buddy! Let's talk about those carbon offsets everybody's buzzing about. As we race against time to slow down climate change, many businesses are turning to carbon offsets as part of their climate action plan. But wait, not everyone's cheerleading this move – folks in the environmental community have mixed feelings, even calling carbon offsets a hindrance. So what the heck are carbon offsets, and are they really our climate-fighting buddy, or just a cunning, carbon-halting scoundrel?

What's a carbon offset, and for whom?

When CO2 pumped into the air gets sucked back out by soaking up the same amount of carbon, it's likeствоdiction: canceling out each other's heating effects. Businesses and individuals can offset their greenhouse gas emissions by supporting projects that either lower or store carbon emissions. For instance, if you've sprung for a flight and paid a little more to cover your carbon footprint, you've bought yourself an offset. Planting trees, promoting solar or wind power, employing farming methods that store carbon in the soil – there are a bunch of ways to offset carbon emissions.

Corporations and individuals dish out cash for carbon offsets to lessen their impact on global warming. Some companies even get serious about it, committing hard to climate action. Others do it because it's sensible for business – legit climate plans have become a must-have for operating in today's sustainability-minded market. Companies that go carbon neutral (read: they offset all their emissions, so they theoretically don't contribute to climate change) can brag about it to their eco-conscious customers, investors, partners, and other stakeholders.

Not only does managing emissions drive the use of offsets, but they've got another ace up their sleeve: Co-benefits. Most carbon offset projects bring extra benefits to the table, such as helping with other environmental issues and supporting local communities. Take the example of a project that kicks off energy-efficient cookstoves in rural Ghanaian communities. Families use less fuel for cooking, meaning fewer emissions and a reduced carbon footprint. Meanwhile, the project helps eliminate poverty by saving families money and lifting a burden off their time, allowing them to do more important stuff like learn or make money. Furthermore, these improved cookstoves cut down on indoor air pollution, leading to positive health effects for families. In other words, buying offsets can help combat climate change while contributing to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), a topic that many businesses are passionate about.

Can carbon offsetting deliver the goods?

With carbon offset projects often taking place far from the point of purchase, it can be tricky to know if the promised actions are being executed as intended. Luckily, a slew of standards (e.g., the Verified Carbon Standard or the Gold Standard) and registries have been developed to ensure projects meet the criteria to be classified as offsets and perform as planned during the design phase.

Obviously, carbon offset projects should indeed keep carbon out of the atmosphere, but even better, they must offer additionality. In plain speak, that's carbon savings that would've happened only through the project. To illustrate, let's go back to the energy-efficient cookstove project. The project managers need to demonstrate additionality by proving that cookstove recipients wouldn't have received those upgraded stoves by some other means, for example through government handouts. Additionality can be proven to a reasonable degree, but due to its nature as an estimate, total certainty is yet to be achieved. Some providers offer offset guarantees: if a project doesn't deliver as expected or turns out to be non-additional, they'll support a different project to make up for it. In a nutshell, offsets do provide carbon benefits, although outcomes may not always be 100% certain unless purchased with a guarantee.

Want More Insight? 👉 What are Carbon Credits and How Do They Work?

Why are carbon offsets controversial?

Outspoken environmental advocates argue that carbon offsets don't tackle the root cause of emissions. Swetha Sekhar of Ecolytics puts it like this: "If your bathtub is overflowing, you don't start mopping – you turn off the tap." This analogy highlights the notion that to address climate change, the major focus should be on stopping the flow of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, not soaking them up with offsets. What's more vexing is that employing offsets without reducing emissions creates an illusory belief that the emission problem has been tackled. Instead, it encourages businesses to stick with a business-as-usual approach while neglecting much-needed emission cuts.

Of course, there's truth to these points, but they don't write off carbon offsets entirely. Businesses must first identify and address the sources of emissions within their operations before turning to offsets as a last-resort solution to clean up the impact of unavoidable emissions. Like turning off a rusty tap takes time, businesses that truly want to fight climate change will implement emissions reduction first and only use offsets to compensate for emissions they can't eliminate on their own. In this sense, carbon offsets can indeed hasten climate action.

It's true that some companies might choose offsetting as their sole climate strategy, dubiously declaring themselves "climate neutral" and using that moniker to capitalize on the climate bandwagon. But companies that dish out serious cash for emission reductions and employ offsets as the cherry on top of a larger climate action plan are the rule, not the exception. In the long run, offsets might not be the silver bullet for reversing climate change. However, they can be a valuable tool in the arsenal of an emissions reduction plan, as long as they're part of a comprehensive plan for significant future carbon emissions reductions.

Carbon offsets have been criticized for slowing climate efforts, but let's also consider whether accessibility might be a positive, eventually normalizing climate action in the business world, getting us one step closer to meaningful emission cuts. So, are carbon offsets the villain of the climate story or its unlikely hero? Tune in over time to see how this story pans out!

Want More Insight? 👉 Carbon Tax Pros and Cons: Is Carbon Pricing the Right Policy to Implement?

Carbon offsets are a means for businesses and individuals to counteract their greenhouse gas emissions by supporting projects that reduce or store carbon emissions.
These projects, such as planting trees or promoting renewable energy, can contribute to various environmental issues and support local communities.
Businesses can use carbon offsets as part of their climate action plan to reduce their impact on global warming, climate change, and other environmental concerns.
Some companies commit to being carbon neutral, offsetting all their emissions, as a strategic move to appeal to eco-conscious customers, investors, and partners.
Standards and registries have been established to verify that these carbon offset projects meet the criteria for carbon reduction and perform as intended.
Critics argue that carbon offsets do not address the root cause of emissions and encourage businesses to delay necessary emission reductions.
For carbon offsets to be effective, businesses should first address sources of emissions within their operations and then use offsets as a last resort to compensate for unavoidable emissions.
Accessibility to carbon offsets may eventually normalize climate action within businesses, bringing us closer to meaningful emission cuts.
The long-term viability of carbon offsets as a solution to climate change depends on their use as part of a comprehensive plan for significant future carbon emissions reductions.