Unveiling the Fall of Cred: A Dark Chapter in Crypto Lending
Former Executives of Cred Admit Guilt in Cryptocurrency Scam Worth $150 Million
In a stunning turn of events, two top executives of defunct crypto lender Cred Inc., Daniel Schatt and Joseph Podulka, are facing up to 72 months in prison following guilty pleas to federal charges of wire fraud conspiracy. Their missteps culminated in losses worth up to $150 million for customers.
Scene: The Rise and Fall of a Crypto Powerhouse
On October 13th, 2020, Cred Inc., once a bustling hub for cryptocurrency trading, filed for bankruptcy. Over 6,000 customer claims, worth more than $140 million, were filed in the aftermath. Now, the former CEO and CFO find themselves standing trial for their actions.
Decrypt's Spotlight: Unmasking the Con
Daniel Schatt and Joseph Podulka admitted in court that they colluded to present an overly optimistic image of Cred's financial health and lending practices in 2020. Judge William Alsup voiced his disapproval, stating they had "acted together with the common goal of presenting an incomplete, unreasonably positive and thus misleading portrayal" of the business.
Liquidity Crunch and a Market Meltdown
Cred's downfall began when Bitcoin crash-landed during the March 2020 flash crash, resulting in a 40% plummet within a single day. This disaster sent shockwaves through Cred, as they struggled to meet their margin calls. In dire straits, Cred attempts to recoup losses by enticing new clients and discouraging redemptions from existing customers.
Chinese Whispers and Unsecured Loans
The wreckage deepened as Cred found itself in a $40 million hole due to a loan from MoKredit, a primary borrower with questionable business practices. Schatt and his team reportedly funneled 80% of customer assets into MoKredit, tethering Cred's solvency to their borrower's repayment potential.
During this time, MoKredit continued to operate under the radar, issuing unsecured microloans to Chinese gamers. The information about this high-risk venture was never disclosed to customers.
Betrayals and Red Flags
Cred's misfortunes took another dramatic turn when their Chief Capital Officer, James Alexander, was accused of absconding with over $2 million in Bitcoin. Separate indictments were unsealed against Alexander in 2021. Schatt also acknowledged the loss of 800 BTC, together valued at over $9 million, due to a "sham" that targeted Cred.
Prosecutors argue for prison sentences of up to 72 months for Schatt and 62 months for Podulka. A sentencing hearing is planned for August 26th, shedding light on the full extent of the damage wrought by these executives' decisions.
Sign up for the Daily Debrief Newsletter for the latest updates on the Cred case and more cryptocurrency news straight to your inbox.
Enrichment Data: A Closer Look at Cred's downfall
The story of Cred's demise is a cautionary tale of misleading customers and risky business practices. Here's a deeper dive into the factors that contributed to its fall:
Disguising the Truth: Hidden Risk
- Overstated Claims: Cred executives made misleading statements, claiming that their lending practices relied on collateralized loans and that all customer assets were hedged. In reality, MoKredit, their primary borrower, represented a significant portion of their unsecured loan portfolio, posing considerable risk for Cred and its customers[1][2][3].
Tied Together: MoKredit and Cred's Fate
- UnSecured Alliance: MoKredit, a Chinese firm that issued unsecured microloans to gamers, accounted for 80% of Cred's loan portfolio, a fact never disclosed to customers[1][3].
The Final Blow: A Market Meltdown and Deceit
- Market Meltdown: The March 2020 flash crash, taking Bitcoin down 40% in a day, crippled Cred's ability to meet margin calls. Despite these significant strains, executives persisted in concealing risks and attracting new business[1][2][3].
- Unraveling the Scam: Schatt and Podulka acknowledged charges of wire fraud, admitting to the selective disclosure of information that ultimately led to losses ranging from $65 million to $150 million[4][5].
Bankruptcy and Loss
- Aftermath of Bankruptcy: The impact of Cred's bankruptcy was steep, with customers reporting losses exceeding $150 million. Yet in May 2024, revalued assets revealed a potential worth of $783 million, illustrating the enormity of the initial financial losses[1][4].
- The criminal charges against Daniel Schatt and Joseph Podulka, the former CEO and CFO of defunct crypto lender Cred Inc., could lead to up to 72 months in prison, following their guilty pleas to federal charges of wire fraud conspiracy.
- In the wake of Cred Inc.'s bankruptcy filing on October 13th, 2020, more than 6,000 customer claims, worth over $140 million, were made.
- Schatt and Podulka admitted to deceiving customers by presenting an overly optimistic image of Cred's financial health and lending practices in 2020, resulting in losses ranging from $65 million to $150 million.
- Cred's downfall can be traced back to the March 2020 flash crash, which caused Bitcoin to plummet by 40% within a day. This catastrophe made it difficult for Cred to meet margin calls.
- A significant portion of Cred's loan portfolio, around 80%, was held by MoKredit, a Chinese firm with questionable business practices. This risky alliance was never disclosed to customers.
- The cryptocurrency scene was shaken by the fall of Cred, reinforcing the need for transparency, honesty, and caution in the crypto market, finance, business, general-news, and crime-and-justice sectors.
